Pre-existing diseases or injuries prior medical examination in health plan contracts and STJ summary 609

Main Article Content

Luciano Pereira de Souza
Carol de Oliveira Abud

Abstract

The constant exclusion of coverage in cases of diseases called preexistinggave rise to a new adequacy of rule, reinforced by STJ Precedent 609. Theemergence of a manifestation of consumer society has brought with it contractualinequalities, especially in adhesion contracts, such as the health insurance contract.Conflicts began to arise and, in order to adjust the current social situation andrebalance the contractual relationship, contractual clauses began to suffer limitations or extensions, many of them through state intervention through judicialization,imposing on contractors (beneficiary of the health plan) and for contractors (healthcare providers) certain rules that are independent of their real will. It is evidenced bythe analysis of legal norms and the summary, the need for pre-admission exams,which would end all doubts about the coverage of pre-existing diseases or injuries.This more modern and social interpretation in situations that occur in health insurancecontracts and its rules regulated by the Health Insurance Law and correspondingregulations of the National Supplementary Health Agency is what we will observe. Thestudy, conducted through documentary and literary review, aims to explore anddemonstrate the need to perform prior examinations to health insurance contracts.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Article Details

Section

Artigos

Author Biographies

Luciano Pereira de Souza, Santa Cecilia University

Doctor (Unisantos), Master (USP) and Bachelor (USP) in Law. Bachelor of Biological Sciences (USP). Permanent Professor of the Stricto Sensu Postgraduate Program, Master's in Health Law (Unisanta). Professor of Criminal Law (Unisanta). Institution of origin: Santa Cecília University – Unisanta – Santos, SP

Carol de Oliveira Abud, Santa Cecilia University

MBA in Business Management (FGV) and Bachelor of Laws (UNIRP/FIRP). Master's student in Health Law (Unisanta). Researcher in the CNPq/Unisanta research group "Human Rights and Sustainable Development" and "Health Law". Home institution: Santa Cecília University – Unisanta – Santos, SP

How to Cite

SOUZA, Luciano Pereira de; ABUD, Carol de Oliveira. Pre-existing diseases or injuries: prior medical examination in health plan contracts and STJ summary 609. Unisanta Law and Social Science, Santos, v. 8, n. 2, p. 161–178, 2024. DOI: 10.66221/v8n2p161. Disponível em: https://periodicosunisanta.ojsbr.com/LSS/article/view/808. Acesso em: 17 mar. 2026.

Most read articles by the same author(s)